Fiche de révision CRFPA

Common Law vs Civil Law

Sources du droit, rôle du juge, precedent et equity : les différences structurantes entre common law et droit civiliste, avec le vocabulaire anglais à maîtriser.

Toutes les fiches

I. Common Law System

  • Origins: English legal tradition, developed through judicial decisions
  • Stare decisis: doctrine of precedent — courts follow previous rulings
  • Sources: case law (judge-made law), statutes, customs
  • Countries: UK, USA, Canada, Australia, India
  • Adversarial system: parties present their case before a neutral judge/jury

II. Civil Law System

  • Origins: Roman law tradition, codified by Napoleon (1804)
  • Codification: comprehensive codes as primary source of law
  • Sources: codes, statutes, regulations (jurisprudence is secondary)
  • Countries: France, Germany, Spain, Japan, most of continental Europe
  • Inquisitorial system: judge actively investigates the facts

III. Key Differences

  • Role of judges: Common Law judges "make" law; Civil Law judges "apply" law
  • Precedent: binding in Common Law; persuasive only in Civil Law
  • Legal reasoning: inductive (case-based) vs deductive (code-based)
Point clé : Understanding the fundamental differences between Common Law and Civil Law systems is essential for the CRFPA English exam, as it forms the basis for many comparative law questions.